It is to be examined how the design of the baffle and the arrangement of the drivers, affect the reproduction quality of loudspeakers. In particular, the attention is paid to the directional behavior, of the tweeter. In addition to the frequency response on axis (0 °), a balanced and uniform directional behavior has a considerable, and in the author's perception sometimes (too) neglected, influence on the playback quality, also and especially in terms of spatial representation of the sound, of speakers.
Imbalances between on-axis, and off-axis frequency responses very often result from an inappropriate baffle design including missplacement of the drivers. The tweeter "sees" the baffle edges in the intended frequency range, where secondary sound sources are created.
Those who value a loudspeaker not only by its tone, but also by a good stage presentation, should take a trained look at the baffle of the speaker in addition to reading impressive sound descriptions. To train this view is the concern of this article ...
In the following, the directional behavior of 25mm tweeters in different installation situations is examined. The influence of midrange speakers is usually less problematic and should not be considered here.
The first four examples are based on (reliable) simulations, assuming an on-axis linearized and 2kHz-separated tweeter. The simulations and measurements show the angles 0,30 & 60 ° horizontal.
First of all, two installation situations without, or with only minimal baffle influence:
The infinite baffle
Uniform, flawless directional behavior, starting from the frequency given by the tweeter surface of the tweeter. No edge diffraction and / or secondary sound sources.
Tweeter with very small front panel, without baffle
The "baffle edges", in this case the edges of the tweeter itself, are so close that the associated frequency is within a range in which the tweeter already no longer works as a half-space radiator. So he does not "see" this practically. The system can be considered as a system without baffle.
Uniform, impeccable directional behavior without problems due to edge diffraction.
The non-existent baffle further stabilizes the directional response to the mid-bass driver, even below the frequency specified by the memranface of the tweeter. Ideal conditions for a seamless connection to the directional behavior of the mid-woofer.
This concept is used in the Kit Center-HQ.
... in the author's point of view
Baffle rectangular, narrow, tweeter in the middle, no waveguide, no chamfers
The tweeter "sees" the baffle edges in the intended working area. => Edge diffraction. The result is an on-axis dip with a peak at angles. In the simulation, the tweeter is linearized, => the dip on the axis has been compensated, which makes the peaks at angles more revealing accordingly. Regardless of how the driver filtered to the axis, the discrepancy between on-axis and off-axis frequency responses remains.
Tonality: Imbalance under different listening positions.
space: The space suffers from the imbalance of axis and angular frequency responses
Usually. such concepts are tuned with a sink on axis, which is then "refilled" under angles. This can sound very good in terms of tonality. In a sensitive area for the ear there is a sink (I like to call it "ear flatterer"), energetically still nothing is missing, because it is compensated under angles.
A second approach would be to separate very high (in this case> 3,5kHz). However, you are dealing with other problems. The bass-midrange already straightens in this area, and is then "replaced" by the tweeter, which is still working as a half-space heater => The energy frequency response is unbalanced. In the area of the cut-off frequency too little energy is released into the room. Furthermore, it becomes more and more unbalanced in the vertical along with an increase of the cut-off frequency. The distance between the drivers must always be in relation to the crossover frequency.
This concept finds application in very many, vA speakers developed under time, and or selling pressure 😉
... with 15mm bevels
Baffle rectangular, narrow, tweeter centered, 15mm bevels on both sides
The chamfers weaken the interference, but the fundamental problem persists. The above written remains valid.
How to deal with the problem?
In addition to the infinite baffle, and the "virtually nonexistent", there are other promising approaches to avoid or significantly reduce edge diffraction.
The following examples are all based on real measurements from speakers I have published. There is no claim to completeness.
Wide baffle with generous rounding on the sides
In this case there is no 60 ° measurement, therefore 0,30 & 45 ° are shown.
No edge diffraction in the intended work area. The (rounded) edges are far enough away that you will not be "seen". Extremely consistent straightening behavior.
This concept was used in the construction proposal Wave Wall 182, Another very appealing speaker that follows a similar approach is eg. the Grimm LS1.
Tweeter positioned off-center with 12mm chamfer sideways and up
Low influence by edge diffraction at 2,2kHz, which can be easily compensated for by a suitable filter from the midrange driver. In addition, uniform and trouble-free omnidirectional behavior.
This concept was used in the construction proposal Samuel HQ
Trapezoidal chamfers with a slope> = 20 °, brought as close as possible to the tweeter
Slight expansion around 5kHz, otherwise no problems due to edge diffraction. The bundling behavior is, characterized in that the tweeter sees only very little baffle, to the directional behavior of the mid-bass, which allows a seamless connection to this only.
The upper chamfer is, depending on the concept, not necessarily needed. Under certain circumstances, the result could even be (even) better without this.
Tweeter with sound guide / waveguide and maximum narrow baffle
No edge diffraction. Extremely uniform straightening behavior in the entire transmission range. In contrast to normal dome tweeters, even in the super high tone (> 10kHz) wide and even radiation. Concerning. horizontal bundling a nearly perfect solution.
However, the distance to the mid-bass driver is greater than without sound conduction, which adversely affects the vertical radiation behavior. This problem is avoided by a correspondingly deeper separation, which, thanks to the sound pressure increasing and thus driver-relieving effect of the waveguide usually. is also feasible.
Sound guide (DXT) & trapezoidal chamfers
The same applies as in the example previously written, but without the problem of the large driver distance. The tweeter used here is the Seas-DXT. The size of a "normal" tweeter (D104mm), with the effect of a true waveguide. Fascinating!
The trapezoidal phases do the rest, especially in terms of stabilization of the bundling behavior towards the mid-bass driver. In wider baffles there would be a widening in the transmission range, usually. to 3kHz which would be compensated only by a correspondingly high crossover frequency.
The horizontal straightening comes very close to the theoretical ideal perceived by the author!
This concept was used in the construction proposal DXT-Mon
At the end...
There are very meaningful and simple approaches to tackle the topic of edge diffraction in tweeters:
- Give it a lot of baffle: The case edges are far enough away so that the tweeter will not see you in the intended work area
- Unsymmetry: If possible, no identical distances between the edges and the tweeter. This can be achieved by the position of the driver (off-center) and / or the design of the baffle. As an example, the Rocket of Hifi DIY mentioned.
- ... along with as little as possible baffle => The straightening behavior is reinforced towards the mid-bass driver, which can greatly facilitate the seamless connection to the midrange woofer (=> eg trapezoidal chamfers).
- Use of sound guides (waveguides, horns) which have a clear directivity in the, for edge diffraction relevant frequency range. Usually. Waveguide solutions should aim for a maximally narrow baffle in order to stabilize its emission towards the mid-bass driver.
... there is only one problematic case
- A rectangular baffle, approximately in the width of the woofer, with central tweeter and without sound guide ...
In my experience, uniform and largely unbroken bundling behavior is one of the most important, if not the least most important quality feature of a good speaker.
The good reader has (hopefully) learned with this article to be able to judge this by looking at a loudspeaker, at least somewhat. A little reading-reading skills is still very helpful ...
It is not sensible to provide existing loudspeakers with chamfers, new baffles, sound guides and / or driver arrangements. In the vast majority of cases, this requires a metrological check and a corresponding adaptation of the crossover.
For questions, suggestions & criticism: Feel free to use the comment function!